MOCKERRY OF FRIENDLY CITIZENS CHARTER!!!!!!

MOCKERRY OF FRIENDLY CITIZENS CHARTER!!!!!!

This is a classic example to prove that much trumpeted grievance handling system of the Govt. of India is just a FARCE.
"Whistleblowing"Commerce Ministry’s fraud On Govt.Employees Covered Under CCS Pension Rules-1972

From 1994 I have not received any reply for over 100 messaegs/appeals/faxes sent asking for information on VRS-1994 but thanks to RTI Act-2005 for getting the original circular of commerce ministry which was edited to cheat the employees.

Export Inspection Council-a statutory body under Commerce Dept. which is also an “administrative ministry” implemented a special voluntary retirement scheme (SVRS)in 1994 fraudulently without involving the NODAL departments-in violation of Allocation of Business Rules & Transaction of Business Rules made by His Excellency The President of India under Article 77(3) of Indian Constitution.

Thus ILLEGAL SVRS-1994 has floated all rules/norms applicable under CCS Pension Rules of 1972 in gross violation of Articles 309, 313, 372 &144 of the Constitution.

This clandestine action is being covered by the following departments willfully for reasons best known to them:

1.Department of Personnel & Training.

2.Department of Pension & Pensioners Welfare.

3.Department of Administrative Reforms & Public Grievances.

4.Central Information Commission.

For more details please visit : http://venkym.blogspot.com/
-----------------------

Record of my efforts in search of justice

FRIENDLY CITIZEN’S CHARTERS!!!! Record of my efforts in search of justice: It took 11years &5 months to get a correct informtion on SVRS.Thanks to Right to Informtion Act-2005 !!!!God only knows when my ordeal will end!!!!!!!!!
1. 30.05.1994 Letter asking EIA, Madras for clarifications on VRS terms.
2. 31.05.1994-MS/ADMN/Gen/94-95-1134 -Refusal reply.
3. 06.06.1994-Letter to EIA, Madras on Pay commission & other doubts. (Not replied)
4. 06.12.1994-Letter on Non payment of VRS benefits. (Not replied)
5. 06.01.1995-Part payment received under protest.
6. 07.01.1995-Letter for pending payment & interest. (No reply)
7. 25.01.1995-Reminder for payment/protest. (No reply)
8. 29.03.1995-Letter to the then Commerce Secretary . (No reply)
9. 29.03.1995-Copy to Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions.
10. 21.04.1995-Reply from above ministry; F.No36306/3/DCOM/PD-95
11. 17.04.1997-Letter to Director for payment of weightage & DA (No reply)
12. 06.10.1997-Part payment received under protest.
13. 13.10.1997-Letter asking full VRS benefits. (No reply)
14. 14.10.1997-Letter to DD on payment. (No reply)
15. 23.11.2000-Appeal to Commerce secretary-citing Calcutta High Court order No: 6373(W) of 1995 Dt.26.11.1996 with copies to the Under Secretary, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions/Secretary-Pension & Pensioners Welfare/Director-Inspection & Quality Control. (No replies).
16. 04.02.2003-Letter to the Secretary, Directorate of Public Grievances-DPG/M/2003/80011 (Replied on 17.02.03).
17. 14.02.2003-Copy to Joint Secretary, Vigilance/Staff grievances (Shri.S.Ramasundaram) fax/email.(No reply)
18. 20.03.2003-Fax Reminder to The Commerce Secretary ( Shri. Dipak Chatterji).
19. 26.03.2003-Final appeal to the Hon’ble Minister for Commerce, Govt. of India.
20. 02.04.2003-Reply fm Shri.Mangal singh,Under Sec.,Dt.28.03.2003.
21. 10.04.2003-sent fax to Under.Sec. for a specific reply on the complaint.(sent post copy also-29/4)
22. 17.05.2003-Reply Dt.09.05.2003 fm Under Sec.
23. 23.06.2003-Recd.copy of communication Dt.31.05.2003sent by Shri.L.V.Saptharishi directing D(Q/C) to give a reply by 15.06.2003.
24. 24.07.2003-Fax reminder to the Addl.Sec.Shri.L.V.Saptharishi. (No reply)
25. 18.08.2003-Fax to Jt.Sec.Shri.P.K.Deb.,DOPT.request for documents.
26. 12.09.2003-EIC reply:vrs/121/2003/4409-dt.9/9/2003 received.(inadequate reply)
27. 13.09.2003 fax appeal for documents to EIC & DOPT (No reply)
28. 21.09.2003 fax reminder for DQC/EIC. (No reply)
29. 02.10.2003 fax reminder for DQC. (No reply)
30. 02,10.2003 fax message for Secretary S.S.Dawra, DOPT (No reply)
31. 02.10.2003 fax message for Jt.Sec.(AT&A)IFC/DOPT (No reply)
32. 06.10.2003 fax copy to EIA,Chennai. (No reply)
33. 15.10.2003 Final fax reminder for DQC.(No reply)
34. 29.10.2003 Fax to shri.S.S.Dawra, Secretary,DOPT.(No reply)
35. 31.10.2003 Fax to shri.Arun Jaitley,Hon’ble Commerce minister.(No reply)
36. 15.11.2003 Fax to DQC/EIC.(No reply)
37. 08.3.2004 Fax to Shri.Alok/Shri.MVPC Sastry with email copies.(No reply)
38. 23.04.04 Fax appeal to DOPT
39. 07.06.2004 DOPT reply recd.-Note sheet.
40. 26.02.2005 Appeal to the Hon’ble President Of India by email/Fax.
41. 18.06.2005 Fax to Dr.Kalaam, Hon’ble President Of India.
42. 20.06.2005 Fax appeal to DQC/EIC.(No reply)
43. 08.08.2005 under Right to Information Act-fax to Secretary, Ministry of Personnel, Pensions & Public Grievances.
44. 17.08.2005 Reply recd from DPT.
45. 04.10.2005 under Right to Information Act-fax to Secretary, Ministry of Commerce.
46. 04.10.2005 Fax to Mr.E.V.K.S.Elangovan-MOS for Commerce.
47. 10.10.2005 EIC finally replied with a letter Dt.21.05.1994 from Ministry of Commerce which admitted that this SVRS-1994 is not approved by the Govt. Of India. In spite of the Govt. refusal for SVRS-1994 The Commerce Ministry has arbitrarily/hurriedly/deliberately implemented the SVRS without involving nodal agency (DPT) in gross violation of Article 77(3) 309 of the Constitution. Hence this ambiguous SVRS-1994 circular Dt.21/5/1994 implemented by Commerce Ministry is ILLEGAL as it has violated the CCS Pension Rules of 1972 & the Articles 309,313,372 and 144 of the Constitution.
Though the scheme was claimed as VOLUNTARY, I was forced to submit the option Vide letter no: EIA: MS/Admn/gen/94-95/1134 dt.31.5.1994 even before clarifying the terms of the scheme on my first query Dt.30.05.1994.
SVRS-1994 circular dated 21st.May 1994 circulated by EIC deliberately omitted the facts contained in the ministry circular. Thus I have been deprived/kept in dark deliberately from opting Normal VRS under CCS pension rules.
I would not have opted this ILLEGAL SVRS-1994 had I received the original ministry’s circular (unedited by EIC).
So I am prepared to REPAY SOCALLED INCENTIVES received by me to ACCEPT THE NORMAL VRS Pension under CCS pension rules.

48. 17.10.2005 sought information under RIAct-2005- No reply
49. 13.12.2005 sent DD for information- Recd. Irrelevant information.
50. 21.12.2005 appeal to EIC appellate authority- No reply
51. 13.03.2006 e-mail to Smt.Shyamalima Banerjee. DIRECTOR (Public Grievances),DAR & PG, New Delhi. No reply. Recd. Directive on 6/5/06 to approach Dr.M.S.Rao,Jt.Sec.commerce.
52. 17.03.2006 reminder to appellate authority- No reply.
53. 18.04.2006 Fax appeal to commerce Secretary to activate EIC. (with copy to EIC)
54. 20.04.2006 Recd. Part of information from EIC.
55. 20.04.2006 Fax to appellate authority. Please kindly note another appeal-RT1124 on the ambiguous EIC circular is still pending before you. (with regard to the suppression of facts & allocation of business rules).
56. 06.05.2006 Latest Appeal to Smt.Shyamalima Banerjee,Diector (public Grievances).
57. 06.05.2006 Appeal copy forwarded to Dr.M.S.Rao
58. 07.05.2005 Appeal c.c to: Staff Grievance Officer, Shri P.K. Mahapatra, Joint Secretary, Room No. 247, Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi (Tele fax No. 23063461; E-mail: pkmahapatra@nic.in ).
55-A 15.05.006 Fax to The Apellate Authority,EIC
59. 16.05.2006 Appeal DPG-59faxed to EIC for onward transmission to Dr.M.S.R
60. 19.05.2006 c.c by fax to:Shri.R.Ramanujam,Jt.Sec.,DOPT
61. 20.05.2006 Fax /email appeal to PMO
62. 31.05.2006 c.c of 61 to Shri.Kamalnath,Commerce minister,GOI.
63. 01.06.2006 c.c -----------do---------Residence
64. 05.06.2006 c.c to Officer incharge,EIA,Chennai.
65. 06.06.2006 RIA-Christy Fernando,EIC Appellate committee.
66. 12.06.2006 RIA-Hon’ble Central Chief Infn.Commissioner.
67. 17.06.2006 c.c of Ref-61 to Commerce Minister.
68. 26.06.2006 c.c of Ref-PMO61 to Central Chief Information Commissioner.
69. 03.07.2006 email to CIC
70. 03.07.2006 email to KABIR (NGO)-Ref-68 (Ack. Mail recd.on4.7.06)
71. 06.07.2006 Fax & email to DQC-asking for ack.Grieva3/3/06 of Com.ministry.
72. 06.07.2006 online Gri.regn-DPG-59(DARPG/E/2006/06471)
73. 14.07.2006 Fax/email Reminder to Griev.cell,Director,commerceDept.FT(coord).
74. 17.07.2006 email to CIC/KABIR
74A.20.07.2006 email reminder-II to EIC/C.Secretary.
75.24.07.2006 email to Smt. Soniya Gandhi,Congress President.
76. 04.08.2006 email to C.Secretary for status report
77. 23.08.2006 Reminder-IV to C.S/EIC
78. 24.08.2006 Fax to Shri.kamalnath,MC&I.
79. 01.09.2006 Fax to DIQC final reminder.
80. 01.09.2006 fax to DARPG with cc to.DOPT,PP&W,PMO
81. 02/3.09.06 Fax to Dr.MSRao,Final reminder
82. 06.09.2006 Fax/email to PKMahapatra Udyog bhawan with cc to EIC
83. 06.09.2006 Fax reply to EIC for rejecting my appeal
84. 12.09.2006 Fax to DARPG -84 with cc to PMO
84a.14.09.2006 Fax to Rahul Sarin. Addl.Secretary, DARPG.
85. 17.09.2006 email to CJI, Ref –CJI-85 with c.c to CJ,Chennai HC.
86. 02.10.2006 Reply to AnjuSharma,Commerce Ministry
87.23.11.2006 Fax to C.Secretary-Final appeal for settlement
88.22.12.2006 Fax to DARPG-88 with c.c to PMO
89.15.12.2007 Fax to DARPG-89 with c.c to PMO on 14/2/07

90. 22.01.2008 Fax/email to Hon’ble President.

91. 04.02.2008 Fax to CJ,Chennai-WP-16155.

92. 09.02.2008 Fax/mail to CIC-Ref.08/02

93. 09.02.2008 Fax to AN Tiwari CIC-Ref.DPT-69

94. 10.02.2008 Fax to CIC

REMINDER-III/2009/08-BY EMAIL

Registration Number : PRSEC/E/2009/01246
Name : Shri Venkatesan.M
Date of Receipt : 27 Jul 2009
Current Status : The petition is transferred
Date of Transfer : 30 Jul 2009
Ministry/Department : Department of Personnel and Training
Officer's Name : Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar
Designation : Joint Secretary (AT&A)
Address : Room No. 109, North BlockNew Delhi
Telephone No. : 23094010
Fax : 011 23092580
E Mail : jsata@nic.in
Note: You are requested to further liaise in the matter directly with Joint Secretary (AT&A), Department of Personnel and Training, Room No. 109, North BlockNew Delhi for further information.
---------------------
REMINDER-III/2009/08-BY EMAIL

From: : M.Venkatesan, September 25, 2009
16, Raja apartments, 15/5A-B.K.N Street, Ref: 2009/08
Westmambalam,
CHENNAI-600 033
email ID : venkym1@gmail.com

Shri Dr Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary(AT&A),
Department of Personnel and Training
Room No.109, North Block,New Delhi-110001.
Tele : 23094010 Fax : 23092580 E- mail:jsata@.nic.in/sarkardk@ias.nic.in
Sir,
Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.
Ref: 1. PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30 July 2009.
2. My subsequent email Ref: 2009/05 Dt. 5 August 2009 with 6 enclosures.
3. Email Reminder-1 Dt.19.08.2009.
4. Fax Reminder-2 Dt.04.09.2009
Please let me know the current status of my petition.
Thanking you,
Sincerely Yours,
Venkatesan.M
Chennai-33

REMINDER-II/2009/07-BY FAX

REMINDER-II/2009/07-BY FAX

From: : M.Venkatesan, September 4, 2009
16, Raja apartments, 15/5A-B.K.N Street, Ref: 2009/07
Westmambalam,
CHENNAI-600 033
email ID : venkym1@gmail.com

Shri Dr Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary(AT&A),
Department of Personnel and Training
Room No.109, North Block,New Delhi-110001.
Tele : 23094010 Fax : 23092580 E- mail:jsata@.nic.in

Sir,
Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.

Ref: 1. PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30 July 2009.
2. My subsequent email Ref: 2009/05 Dt. 5 August 2009 with 6 enclosures.
3. Email Reminder-1 Dt.19.08.2009.

Since I have been instructed to liaise in this matter directly with you I earnestly appeal to you to expedite & end my agony. Violations of Commerce Ministry & EIC are placed before you with documentary evidences and kindly inform the actions initiated in this regard as soon as possible.
Please acknowledge the receipt of this letter.
Thanking you.
Sincerely Your’s,

Venkatesan.M
Chennai-33

Post copy confirmation of fax sent by email to: jsata@.nic.in
Fax sent at 11.39hrs

I-REMINDER-EMAIL-19th.AUG.2009

to jsata@nic.in
date 19 August 2009 13:37
subject Reminder-1
mailed-by gmail.com

hide details 19 Aug

From.
Venkatesan.M Ref: 2009/05
16, Raja Apartments,15(5A) B.K.N street,
Westmambalam, Chennai-33
To.
Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary (AT&A),
Department of Personnel and Training,
Room No. 109, North Block, New Delhi. Mail ID: jsata@nic.in

Sir,
Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.
Ref: PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30th.July2009.

As the 1994-SVRS is illegal, DOPT has to take corrective measures by suitable directions to the Commerce Ministry to issue my pension payment order (PPO for Normal retirement benefits or as per 2002 SVRS circular) from the date of my relief-19.07.1994.
Please expedite as soon as possible.

Thanking you,
Sincerely Your’s,
Venkatesan.M
5 August 2009

Enclosures:
1. Copy of MANIPULATED CIRCULAR OF EIC issued to all employees.
2. Copy of Original Commerce Ministry circular recd. under RTI Act-2005.
3. DOPT letter No.134/2005-Estt (A) Dt.17.08.2005.
4. Copy of SVRS issued by DOPT, circulated to EIC employees in 2002.
5. Copy of DOPTcircular.F.No.27/8/2007/EO/SM.II Dt.28.12.2007.
6. Copy of EIC letter rejecting my settlement offer.
VENKATESAN.M
Mob:9444030900
Skype:venkym9971

5th.SEP.2009 LETTER TO JS(AT&A) OF DOPT

From.
Venkatesan.M Ref: 2009/05
16, Raja Apartments,15(5A) B.K.N street,
Westmambalam, Chennai-33
To.
Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary (AT&A),
Department of Personnel and Training,
Room No. 109, North Block, New Delhi. Mail ID: jsata@nic.in

Sir,
Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.
Ref: PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30th.July2009.

As the 1994-SVRS is illegal, DOPT has to take corrective measures by suitable directions to the Commerce Ministry to issue my pension payment order (PPO for Normal retirement benefits or as per 2002 SVRS circular) from the date of my relief-19.07.1994.
Please expedite as soon as possible.

Thanking you,
Sincerely Your’s,
Venkatesan.M
5 August 2009

Enclosures:
1. Copy of MANIPULATED CIRCULAR OF EIC issued to all employees.
2. Copy of Original Commerce Ministry circular recd. under RTI Act-2005.
3. DOPT letter No.134/2005-Estt (A) Dt.17.08.2005.
4. Copy of SVRS issued by DOPT, circulated to EIC employees in 2002.
5. Copy of DOPTcircular.F.No.27/8/2007/EO/SM.II Dt.28.12.2007.
6. Copy of EIC letter rejecting my settlement offer.

FIRST RESPONSE

Your Request/Grievance Registration Number is : PRSEC/E/2009/01246

Registration Number : PRSEC/E/2009/01246
Name : Shri Venkatesan.M
Date of Receipt : 27 Jul 2009
Current Status : The petition is transferred
Date of Transfer : 30 Jul 2009
Ministry/Department : Department of Personnel and Training
Officer's Name : Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar
Designation : Joint Secretary (AT&A)
Address : Room No. 109, North Block
New Delhi

Telephone No. : 23094010
Fax : 011 23092580
E Mail : jsata@nic.in
Note: You are requested to further liaise in the matter directly with Joint Secretary (AT&A), Department of Personnel and Training, Room No. 109, North BlockNew Delhi for further information.

AUTO RESPONSE

Your Request/Grievance has been registered vide Registration number PRSEC/E/2009/01246 .Please quote the same in your future correspondance.

GRIEVANCE PETITION TO Rashtrapati bhavan website

href="file:///C:%5CDOCUME%7E1%5CVENKAT%7E1%5CLOCALS%7E1%5CTemp%5Cmsohtml1%5C01%5Cclip_filelist.xml" rel="File-List">

MOCKERY OF CITIZEN’S CHARTERS!!!

&

CALLOUS ATTIUDE OF DOPT/DARPG

Hon’ble Presidentji,

Sub: Illegal VRS/Clandestine actions by Commerce Ministry

Namaste. You are the custodian of Pensions Act-1871 which protects the rights of pensioners. I am a senior citizen not begging for alms but fighting for my pension rights (covered by CCSPension Rules-1972).

Export inspection agency, under the Commerce Ministry has fraudulently introduced a SVRS in 1994 without involving the DOPT (department of personnel & training) in violation of Constitutional provisions-Art.77/3.

DOPT under the direct control of the Hon’ble Prime Minister is avoiding its responsibility. Instead of using its Super ordinate powers to declare the Subordinate Commerce Ministry’s SVRS-1994 circular( an executive fiat) as NULL & VOID, pushing me from pillar to post.

I am prepared to surrender my ILLEGAL benefits received with interest to accept my normal retirement benefits (47A) which is permitted by treasury rules.

I request you to end my long agony by directing DOPT to redress my grievance expeditiously.

Thanking you.

Sincerely Your’s,

(Venkatesan.M)

16,Raja Apartments,15(5A) B.K.N street,

Westmambalam, Chennai-33

Sunday, 2009-07-26

Ref:2009/04